A band’s debut album can be a really exciting thing. Something about the freshness of the sound hits you at the right moment and then it becomes a meaningful soundtrack for that point in your life. After some time, you may go a long period without revisiting that album. Though when you do, it can really take you back. And regardless of whatever happened to that band afterwards, the transcending feeling you get from a solid debut album stays with you.
That happened for me when Fitz & the Tantrums released their debut album Pickin’ Up the Pieces during August of 2010. I had first become aware of the indie pop and neo soul group a few months prior when they opened for Sharon Jones & the Dap-Kings in Nashville the day before graduating college. As a graduation present to myself, I wanted to see Sharon Jones with some friends because she was an artist I championed regularly on my college radio show dedicated to independent soul and R&B music. Considering that I did not know the opening act, I was not as excited. Frankly, I do not even remember looking them up prior to the show. And, in retrospect, I am glad I did not because I was completely surprised by how great they were.
Michael Fitzpatrick and Noelle Scaggs were exceptionally dynamic and wonderful performers. And their danceable infectious blend of indie pop and soul was incredibly exciting to me. Too bad I was on the eve of graduating from college and once I had that degree in my hand, I was no longer a student and therefore could not be on the college station anymore.
During that summer, one of my close friends had been promoted to upper management at the station and would be in charge the following school year. I was still very excited about Fitz & the Tantrums from seeing them perform and Nashville and told him about the show. Thinking about the campus concert fundraiser the station put on every fall, I told my friend about Fit & the Tantrums and that they should book them because they had a great sound and would certainly get too big for the station rather soon. When asked what the genre was, I told him a blend of indie pop and soul and I was told that sounded terrible. It made me recall a time from a few years earlier when I told the station manager then that we had to book Sharon Jones & the Dap-Kings for one of the concert fundraisers before they too got way too big for us, and I was shot down because the manager’s belief that soul music was no longer relevant.
Just like before, my suggestion for Fitz & the Tantrums was shot down because of some maligned view on taste. While I ended up being correct that Sharon Jones and Fitz & the Tantrums got big in their own right, I realized at the time that my friend was probably busy planning the next year for the station and the last thing he needed was someone from the old guard who had recently graduated sticking around. I had heard similar complaints the last few years when someone graduated but still felt the need to give their input on station direction. I then moved on and jammed to the Pickin’ Up the Pieces album for months on end.
When Fitz & the Tantrums announced their follow-up More Than Just a Dream in 2013, I was beyond excited. Certainly, this album would be great. Perhaps not as great as their debut, but still awesome. And when I got it, I found myself so incredibly disappointed. They had moved away from the soul grooves that made Pickin’ Up the Pieces so great which made a post-graduate former college radio soul DJ so happy. However, I guess that is how it goes when bands plan their career course and aesthetic trajectory. While I am sure the soul music was still in their hearts, it seemed that they were wanting to move into a more commercial pop direction. And based on the releases since then, it appears that would be the case.
Fitz & the Tantrums is the only act I can think of that completely excited me with their debut, but then left me longing for so much more on the next release. And then I kept hanging on hoping for another great album like Pickin’ Up the Pieces, but it never came. So, eventually, I just tuned out completely.
It has been a decade since Fitz & the Tantrums released Pickin’ Up the Pieces and it still bops. Though the album was dropped on August 24th, 2010, the first single “MoneyGrabber” was not released until August 15th, 2011. A fun and catchy tune about not being burned twice by returning to the gold-digging former flame, “MoneyGrabber” was such a great song that captured the style, sound, and essence of what I came to love about Fitz & the Tantrums upon their debut. And while I applaud them for finding the commercial success they have sought with their newer sounds, I still have Picking Up the Pieces to enjoy and bring me back to a time that was simpler. And I look forward to listening to it for more decades to come.